Fantasy Football
“How your Top 101 Picks (FULL PPR) SHOULD GO 1 Ja’Marr Chase 👑 2 Jahmyr Gibbs 3 Bijan Robinson 4 Saquon Barkley 5 Ceedee Lamb 6 Justin Jefferson 7 Christian McCaffrey 8 Malik Nabers 9 Nico Collins 10 Amon-Ra St Brown 11 Brian Thomas Jr 12 Puka Nacua”
Original Tweet
https://t.co/05rQUV6WGx
What Would Make This True
Take is TRUE if the author's top-12 draft board outperforms consensus ADP rankings in terms of aggregate PPR scoring and efficiency. Take is FALSE if consensus ADP reflects better season-long value and most of these picks underperform their suggested slots.
45
Boldness
50/100
Accuracy
Verdict
DIRECTIONALLY RIGHTDynasty Dad's top-12 PPR draft board was largely consensus-accurate for the players who stayed healthy — Chase at #1, Bijan Robinson, Gibbs, and Barkley in the top tier all performed well, with Robinson finishing as RB2 in PPR and McCaffrey finishing as the overall RB1. However, significant misses drag the score down: Malik Nabers (ranked #8) was the biggest bust of the season at his position after missing 13 games with injury, Nico Collins hit concussion protocol mid-season limiting his output, CeeDee Lamb missed ~4 games and posted his lowest totals since his rookie year, and Justin Jefferson was ranked far too low at #6 while Jaxon Smith-Njigba — completely absent from this list — finished as the AP Offensive Player of the Year with a league-leading 1,793 receiving yards. The board got the general tier structure mostly right but several specific slot placements and omissions proved costly.