THE TAKE
It is outrageous to have Justin Herbert ahead of Drake Maye in a QB poll. Herbert is one of the worst playoff quarterbacks ever, though that could change.
BOLDNESS
52/100
GRADE
—
PLAYERS / TEAMS
Justin HerbertDrake Maye
GRADING CRITERIA
TRUE IF
consensus QB rankings place Herbert below Maye;
FALSE IF
Herbert is ranked ahead of or equal to Maye in major NFL power rankings or QB tier lists.
contrariannarrative
This take hasn't been graded yet. Resolution expected JAN 15, 2027.